Why? / 03

Does more choice really help us choose?

If 20 profiles can include the right person, do 200 profiles necessarily help us more?

· 3 min read

This is the kind of question Marina F. Thomas, Alice Binder and Jörg Matthes studied in research published in Computers in Human Behavior in 2022. Their work brings together two studies: a first one with 667 adults, then an experiment with 248 adults aged 18 to 38.

In the experiment, participants were faced with three levels of partner availability. The numbers below represent only the exposure protocol, not the size of a psychological effect.

11profiles shown
31profiles shown
91profiles shown

In this experiment, participants exposed to more profiles reported more choice overload and a greater fear of being single, as well as lower momentary self-esteem.

The finding is interesting because it separates two ideas that are easily confused: having options and being constantly exposed to more options. Reducing the second does not necessarily mean removing the first.

So the study does not measure the “quality” of the people shown, and it does not say that a narrower choice guarantees a better match. Rather, it shows that, in this protocol, high perceived availability goes hand in hand with more choice overload and shifts several short-term psychological measures.

  1. Marina F. Thomas, Alice Binder & Jörg Matthes, “The agony of partner choice: The effect of excessive partner availability on fear of being single, self-esteem, and partner choice overload”, Computers in Human Behavior, vol. 126, 2022, article 106977. Study 1: 667 adults aged 18 to 67; study 2: 248 adults aged 18 to 38. See the study.
Notify me at launch

Read next

Has dating become a second job? →When a like costs almost nothing, is it still a choice? →